top of page
Search

Passing up another Tone-Deaf Pitch

gpgottlieb
Nov 1
4 min read
alex-guillaume-IWnuBhG_y34-unsplash
alex-guillaume-IWnuBhG_y34-unsplash

Dear Authors,

I have interviewed nearly 300 authors and receive DOZENS of weekly pitches from people wanting to be interviewed for New Books in Literature, a podcast channel on the New Books Network. Today, I’d like to share another pitch that missed the mark, in hopes it’ll help you hone your pitching skills. You’ll probably roll your eyes at some of the things this guy says, because you know better, don’t you? I’m not trying to shame anyone, so I've altered names and content.


Hi G. P.,  

I'd love to be a guest on New Books in Literature to talk about my crime novel Women Who Kill (7/7/2027), Book 1 of The Stupid Ass Women Series. I saw your conversation with (one of the nearly 300 authors I’ve interviewed), and I think my book fits that same space. Cereal Killers leaves readers not knowing who to root for: the cops investigating the killers, the killers taking out pedophiles, or the wasted boxes of cereal. I’d like to talk about moral ambiguity in murder mysteries and why women deserve to be villains and antiheroes, not just victims, which I wrote about for Women in Crime Magazine. I'm an Army veteran and a gynecologist, and that background shapes the book's procedural detail. Past guest spots: the famous Women in Crime Podcast and The Best Little Podcast in Texas. The full description of my book is in my NBN pitch form submission. Buy links: TPGoose.com/PhD1

 

Thank you,  Theo Goose   

I want to subscribe to the newsletter. Unchecked

 

1.      First, check the box, Goose. That shows interest in my work, not just your own.

2.     “I'd love to be a guest on New Books in Literature to talk about my crime novel.”

How about opening with a specific reference to an interview you listened to? Prove you don’t just want a platform.  

3.     I saw your conversation with XXXXX, and I think my book fits that same space.  Substitute with something real, not a vague reference to space. I don’t know what space you mean.

  1. Cereal Killers leaves readers not knowing who to root for: the cops investigating the killers, the killers taking out pedophiles, or the wasted boxes of cereal. Telling me how readers feel isn’t a description. Name your protagonist and describe a situation, eg: “Sam Duck didn’t know about the underbelly of Eggville until he had to save it from being scrambled.”  

5.      I’d like to talk about moral ambiguity in murder mysteries and why women deserve to be villains and antiheroes, not just victims, which I wrote about for Women in Crime Magazine. Oh dear – How about, “Here are a few things we can discuss.”  I don’t care if the only thing you’ve written is your novel, but I want to know you’re going to be a worthwhile guest for the hundreds of listeners who download these interviews every week.

6.      I'm an Army veteran and a gynecologist, and that background shapes the book's procedural detail.  Credentials aren’t helpful, Mr. Goose, but thank you for your service. Can you show me a specific example? EG, “I used my training as a doctor and two years of defusing bombs in Iraq to create heart-pounding scenes of devastation.”

7.      Past guest spots: the famous Women in Crime Podcast and The Best Little Podcast in Texas podcast. Pitching for an interview is not a place to brag about other interviews unless you have something warm to say about them.

8.       The full description of my book is in my NBN pitch form submission. Buy links: Theo Goose. Buy links: TPGoose.com/sh1 . NO, Mr. Goose, I will not search through 400 submissions to find yours. If you can’t intrigue me with a short description in your pitch, why would I take the time to read further? And do you realize how insulting it is to ask me to interview you and then assume I’m going to buy your books?


I wouldn't have had to write this essay if Mr. Goose had sent the following pitch. Thanks to ClaudeAI for creating the following improved pitch based on my more extensive crabby list of things not to do:

shirish-suwal-RFoLiaq5TTc-unsplash
shirish-suwal-RFoLiaq5TTc-unsplash

Subject: NBN Pitch: Cereal Killers, a crime novel where the antiheroes hunt predators

 

Dear G.P.,

I listened to your conversation with [Author] about [specific topic from the episode], and your question about [specific question] made me rethink how I wrote my own villains. I’d love to be considered as a guest.

 

My novel Cereal Killers (July 7, 2027) follows [protagonist name], a [role], who is tasked with catching a group of women killing pedophiles, and the more she learns about them, the harder it becomes to say who the real threat is.

 

A few things I’d enjoy digging into with you: why women are so rarely allowed to be villains or antiheroes in crime fiction, and where readers’ sympathy shifts when the victims aren’t innocent. I explored this in an essay for Women in Crime Magazine, and the question keeps pulling me deeper.

 

I’m a gynecologist and an Army veteran, and both shaped the book. [One concrete example: “My years as an Army doctor taught me how to stay calm in a crisis, which I used to write a pivotal emergency scene.”]

I enjoyed being interviewed on the Women in Crime Podcast because [specific, warm detail].

 

I’ve submitted the full description through your pitch form and subscribed to your newsletter. Thank you for your time and for the work you do for authors.

 

Warmly, Theo Goose

 

Can you see how much more successful a thoughtful pitch might be? I will admit to being a little snippy in my response to the real Mr. Goose, but I won’t do that to you because now you know how to pitch like a mensch:


Keep it short (under 200 words). Offer something valuable to listeners. Name the episode you listened to and tell me what you thought about it. Proofread. See what happens.

 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page